Was it suicide?  By Ella Wheeler Wilcox.

New York: F. Tennyson Neely, 1897.
164, [14] p. 20 cm.  

Click Here to see all Editions and Covers 


   Most of Ella Wheeler Wilcox's lines are sounds from the unconscious rather than reflection's echoes. Spiritism might give the key to the psychic phenomenon of the poet's girlhood.  At that period, in spite of her incomplete training, or, perhaps thanks to the absence of many traditional fetters--literary and ethical--a little star suddenly appeared and radiated its sympathetic light.  With no wordly experience, probably on account of her very innocence, a simple, modest, ingenuous lass moved numberless readers with hymns of three-fold love:

"The brain's response, the warm blood's rapturous glow,
The soul's sweet language . . . ."
   Material comforts for a mother must be won quickly, and verse after verse flies into editors' mail.  Many go to waste-baskets, some are returned, others printed uncredited, and a few bring back a little money to the home that shelters beloved ones.  As many as ten poems a day at times go forth from the Western hamlet to edify the great world beyond and to add another leaf to the poet's laurel crown.
   So prolific a pen occasionally grows impatient at mechanical trifles.  It is no wonder that pedantic critics discover flaws in some of her verses--errors of which they would be incapable because they cannot write except about other's writings--like gnats that do not create, nurture, nor admire flowers, yet gnaw at their tender petals.
   These censors forget that the mode of expressing an idea is less important than the idea itself.  An imperfect technique would certainly be undesirable; but a perfect one, with nothing more, is useless in the race for literary spurs.  Rhetorical ability is attainable by all, save idiots.  In fact, our compulsory education has forced every citizen to write, or to imagine he could write, but it has not added one atom of genius to our nation.  Perfection of expression is valuable only when the thoughts thus treated are judicious and appropriate.  Not even all this, however, could gain entree into the Court of Letters.  When one has nothing new to say, or cannot make his own bouquet of other men's roses, he is a pleb, not a prince.
   Ella Wheeler Wilcox has evoked harmonies from every string of the human harp.  Out of the mysterious recesses of her spirit, with a well-garnished mind, excited by the ardor of a blood of Saxon origin, yet Latin in warmth, she has fascinatingly sung the whole gamut of life's tones.
     The Waldorf, New York, July 15, 1897.


  1. Was It Suicide?
  2. Dave's Wife
  3. An Angel's Whisper
  4. Dick's Family
  5. The Old Man's Christmas
  6. Nance
  7. "An Ideal Head."
  8. John Smith's Thanksgiving

Return to Ella Wheeler Wilcox Home Page
Created by: Richard A. Edwards
Email richard@ellawheelerwilcox.org
Last Updated: 8/23/2000